$899,999
74 Elkhart Street
Staten Island, NY 10308
MLS# 2600189
4 beds  |  2 baths  |  1920 sqft


2-web-or-mls-7RV02679
  1 / 54  
2-web-or-mls-7RV02679 3-web-or-mls-7RV02684 1-web-or-mls-7RV02654 Screenshot_20260109_223532_Flexmls Pro 58-web-or-mls-7RV02339 59-web-or-mls-7RV02354 61-web-or-mls-7RV02334 49-web-or-mls-7RV02444 51-web-or-mls-7RV02405 57-web-or-mls-7RV02394 55-web-or-mls-7RV02379 60-web-or-mls-7RV02369 53-web-or-mls-7RV02419 54-web-or-mls-7RV02429 48-web-or-mls-7RV02434 40-web-or-mls-7RV02494 37-web-or-mls-7RV02519 47-web-or-mls-7RV02479 46-web-or-mls-7RV02469 50-web-or-mls-7RV02454 45-web-or-mls-7RV02459 44-web-or-mls-7RV02489 ChatGPT Image Jan 9, 2026, 03_19_49 PM 43-web-or-mls-7RV02484 41-web-or-mls-7RV02499 ChatGPT Image Jan 9, 2026, 03_19_52 PM 42-web-or-mls-7RV02509 29-web-or-mls-7RV02574 30-web-or-mls-7RV02579 31-web-or-mls-7RV02584 25-web-or-mls-7RV02589 32-web-or-mls-7RV02534 34-web-or-mls-7RV02549 39-web-or-mls-7RV02529 35-web-or-mls-7RV02554 36-web-or-mls-7RV02564 ChatGPT Image Jan 9, 2026, 03_49_31 PM 27-web-or-mls-7RV02599 24-web-or-mls-7RV02619 Screenshot_20260109_223814_ChatGPT ChatGPT Image Jan 9, 2026, 03_01_01 PM 20-web-or-mls-7RV02639 18-web-or-mls-7RV02694 15-web-or-mls-7RV02699 12-web-or-mls-7RV02724 13-web-or-mls-7RV02729 16-web-or-mls-7RV02704 17-web-or-mls-7RV02714 Screenshot_20260109_223621_Flexmls Pro Screenshot_20260110_100851_Flexmls Pro 14-web-or-mls-DJI_20260108132938_0005_D Screenshot_20260109_223645_Flexmls Pro Screenshot_20260110_100836_Flexmls Pro 7-web-or-mls-DJI_20260108133200_0032_D

Property Description
Welcome home to 74 Elkhart Street! Discover an extraordinary raised Cape, nestled within the coveted Great Kills neighborhood, that transcends the ordinary boundaries of suburban living. Architectural charm converges with the rare privilege of backing directly onto King Fisher Park's pristine wilderness. This remarkable residence presents an increasingly elusive opportunity—a home where your backyard neighbor happens to be nature itself, complete with meandering walking trails and a tranquil fishing pond that beckons wildlife enthusiasts and serenity seekers alike. Encompassing 1,920 square feet of thoughtfully appointed living space, this fully detached sanctuary unfolds across multiple levels of sophisticated comfort. The main floor welcomes you with a harmonious flow between the spacious living room and elegant dining room, where meticulously restored hardwood floors create a warm foundation for memorable gatherings. The oversized kitchen stands as the heart of this home, designed with the passionate entertainer in mind, offering generous space for culinary adventures. A dedicated door from the kitchen opens directly to the yard, creating seamless indoor-outdoor connectivity for effortless al fresco entertaining. This level also features a convenient three-quarter bathroom, providing essential functionality for guests and daily living alike. The thoughtful floor plan includes a versatile first-level room currently serving as a professional office, yet easily transformed back to its intended purpose as a fourth bedroom—adapting seamlessly to life's evolving needs. Ascend to discover three well-proportioned bedrooms, including a substantial primary suite blessed with abundant closet space for the most discerning wardrobe. A full bathroom on this level provides convenience and ease of access.

Details
Maps
Address/Legal
Section: South Shore
Country: United States
Contract/Location Information
List Price/SqFt: 468.75
End Unit: No
Ownership Type: Fee Simple
CofO: Yes
List Type: Exclusive Right to Sell
REO: No
Owner Finance: No
General Property Info
Stories: 2
Style: Cape
Taxes: 8194.56
Half Baths: 0
Tax Abated: No
Lot Size SqFt: 5000
Year Built Description: Approx
Lot Dim: 50 x 100
Irregular: no
No. of Heating Units: 1
Air Conditioner: Units
Condition: Excellent
Total Rooms Main Unit: 9
3/4 Baths: 1
Garage Location: None
Basement Type: Full
Public Remarks: Welcome home to 74 Elkhart Street! Discover an extraordinary raised Cape, nestled within the coveted Great Kills neighborhood, that transcends the ordinary boundaries of suburban living. Architectural charm converges with the rare privilege of backing directly onto King Fisher Park's pristine wilderness. This remarkable residence presents an increasingly elusive opportunity—a home where your backyard neighbor happens to be nature itself, complete with meandering walking trails and a tranquil fishing pond that beckons wildlife enthusiasts and serenity seekers alike. Encompassing 1,920 square feet of thoughtfully appointed living space, this fully detached sanctuary unfolds across multiple levels of sophisticated comfort. The main floor welcomes you with a harmonious flow between the spacious living room and elegant dining room, where meticulously restored hardwood floors create a warm foundation for memorable gatherings. The oversized kitchen stands as the heart of this home, designed with the passionate entertainer in mind, offering generous space for culinary adventures. A dedicated door from the kitchen opens directly to the yard, creating seamless indoor-outdoor connectivity for effortless al fresco entertaining. This level also features a convenient three-quarter bathroom, providing essential functionality for guests and daily living alike. The thoughtful floor plan includes a versatile first-level room currently serving as a professional office, yet easily transformed back to its intended purpose as a fourth bedroom—adapting seamlessly to life's evolving needs. Ascend to discover three well-proportioned bedrooms, including a substantial primary suite blessed with abundant closet space for the most discerning wardrobe. A full bathroom on this level provides convenience and ease of access.
Pool Y/N: No
Waterview: No
Fireplace: No
HOA Y/N: No
Year Built: 1965
Building SqFt: 1920
Bedrooms: 4
Full Baths: 1
Total Baths: 2
Sewer
City: 1
Appliances
Dishwasher: 1
Dryer: 1
Microwave: 1
Refrigerator: 1
Washer: 1
Dining Room
Formal: 1
Separate: 1
Electric
220: 1
Exterior
Deck: 1
Fence: 1
Shed: 1
Heat Source
Gas: 1
Heat System
Steam: 1
Interior
Ceiling Fan: 1
Kitchen
Eat In: 1
Yard/Deck Access: 1
Living Room
Formal: 1
Separate: 1
Main Bath
3 Quarter: 1
Primary Bedroom
Shared Bath: 1
Parking
Off Street: 1
Garage Location
None: 1
Siding
Vinyl Siding: 1
Yard
Back: 1
AddressLegal
Street No.: 74
Street Name: Elkhart
Street Suffix: Street
County: Richmond
State: NY
Zip Code: 10308
Area Name: Great Kills
Parcel ID: 04593-0023
ContractLocation Information
Status: Active
Marketing/Listing Date: 2026-01-09
List Price: $899,999
Current Price: $899,999
Sub-Type: Single Family - Detached
Zoning: R2
Block: 04593
Lot: 0023
Property Features
Appliances: Dishwasher; Dryer; Microwave; Refrigerator; Washer
Dining Room: Formal; Separate
Exterior: Deck; Fence; Shed
Heat Source: Gas
Heat System: Steam
Interior: Ceiling Fan
Kitchen: Eat In; Yard/Deck Access
Living Room: Formal; Separate
Main Bath: 3 Quarter
Primary Bedroom: Shared Bath
Parking: Off Street
Garage Location: None
Siding: Vinyl Siding
Yard: Back
Electric: 220
Supplements
The fully finished basement emerges as this property's crown jewel, pre-wired for surround sound and equipped with French drainage systems ensuring perpetual dryness. Whether envisioned as additional living quarters, a recreational haven, or personal fitness sanctuary, this 520-square-foot subterranean retreat offers endless possibilities. A concealed laundry room maintains the space's polished aesthetic while providing essential functionality. Step outside onto the expansive deck, where the generous 50x100 lot reveals its true splendor. The substantial backyard creates a private oasis where morning coffee transforms into a nature documentary, and evening barbecues unfold against a backdrop of parkland serenity. An extended driveway accommodates three vehicles with gracious ease. This move-in-ready gem represents more than mere homeownershipit's an invitation to embrace a lifestyle where urban convenience meets natural tranquility. Don't let this rare opportunity to claim your slice of Staten Island paradise slip through your fingersschedule your private tour today and prepare to fall in love. This home will not last!

Listing Courtesy of Prodigy Real Estate Inc.

Listing data provided courtesy of Staten Island Multiple Listing Service. The information being provided is for consumers personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.