$3,499,999
Staten Island, NY 10305
MLS# 2507003
14250 sqft

1 / 16
Property Description
A rare opportunity to acquire a strategically located multi-building investment portfolio consisting of five income-producing properties plus an additional lot. All assets are positioned in close proximity along St. Mary's Avenue and Tompkins Avenue in Staten Island, NY 10305. This well-assembled portfolio offers operational efficiency, diversified income streams, and strong long-term value potential. It includes a balanced mix of multifamily and commercial properties, making it ideal for investors, developers, or 1031 exchange buyers seeking scale. * The portfolio includes 160 St. Mary's Avenue, a mixed-use property featuring a ground-floor commercial deli with long-standing occupancy, plus two residential units above consisting of a second-floor four-bedroom apartment and a third-floor five-bedroom apartment. Also included is 162 St. Mary's Avenue, a two-family property with two well-proportioned two-bedroom apartments. 164 St. Mary's Avenue is a three-family property offering a first-floor studio apartment and two-bedroom apartments on both the second and third floors. 166 St. Mary's Avenue is a two-family property with two two-bedroom apartments. In addition, 488 Tompkins Avenue features a commercial storefront currently operating as a barbershop, along with an adjacent lot located between 488 Tompkins Avenue and 160 St. Mary's Avenue, suitable for parking, storage, yard use, or potential future expansion, subject to buyer due diligence with an architect and the Department of Buildings. The portfolio is located in a prime Staten Island corridor with convenient access to public transportation, ferry routes, shopping centers, and local amenities. The commercial spaces benefit from strong visibility and foot traffic, while the residential units experience consistent rental demand and stable tenancy. Well positioned for value-add strategies, rental optimization, or long-term hold, this portfolio also offers potential assemblage opportunities .
Details
Maps
Address/Legal
Section: North Shore
Country: United States
International YN: No
Contract/Location Information
List Price/SqFt: 245.61
Sale/Lease: Sale
CofO: Yes
List Type: Exclusive Right to Sell
Owner Finance: No
General Property Info
# of Buildings: 5
Stories: 3
Taxes: 36225
Tax Abated: No
Lot Size SqFt: 9799
Year Built Info: Approx
Lot Dim: 100'X100'
Irregular: No
Air Conditioner: Units
Condition: Good
Garage Capacity: 0
# of Parking Spaces: 0
# Units: 9
Lease Purchase: No
# of Residential Units: 9
# of Commercial Units: 2
# of Mfg Units: 0
# of Medical Units: 0
# of Non-Conform Units: 0
Public Remarks: A rare opportunity to acquire a strategically located multi-building investment portfolio consisting of five income-producing properties plus an additional lot. All assets are positioned in close proximity along St. Mary's Avenue and Tompkins Avenue in Staten Island, NY 10305. This well-assembled portfolio offers operational efficiency, diversified income streams, and strong long-term value potential. It includes a balanced mix of multifamily and commercial properties, making it ideal for investors, developers, or 1031 exchange buyers seeking scale. *
The portfolio includes 160 St. Mary's Avenue, a mixed-use property featuring a ground-floor commercial deli with long-standing occupancy, plus two residential units above consisting of a second-floor four-bedroom apartment and a third-floor five-bedroom apartment. Also included is 162 St. Mary's Avenue, a two-family property with two well-proportioned two-bedroom apartments. 164 St. Mary's Avenue is a three-family property offering a first-floor studio apartment and two-bedroom apartments on both the second and third floors. 166 St. Mary's Avenue is a two-family property with two two-bedroom apartments. In addition, 488 Tompkins Avenue features a commercial storefront currently operating as a barbershop, along with an adjacent lot located between 488 Tompkins Avenue and 160 St. Mary's Avenue, suitable for parking, storage, yard use, or potential future expansion, subject to buyer due diligence with an architect and the Department of Buildings.
The portfolio is located in a prime Staten Island corridor with convenient access to public transportation, ferry routes, shopping centers, and local amenities. The commercial spaces benefit from strong visibility and foot traffic, while the residential units experience consistent rental demand and stable tenancy. Well positioned for value-add strategies, rental optimization, or long-term hold, this portfolio also offers potential assemblage opportunities .
Year Built: 1931
Building SqFt: 14250
Sewer
City: 1
Use Restrictions
None: 1
Electric
220: 1
Showing Instructions
Call Agent: 1
Heat Source
Gas: 1
Heat System
Hot Water: 1
Expenses Include
Insurance: 1
Taxes: 1
Utilities: 1
Electric Meters
Individual: 1
Gas Meters
Individual: 1
Parking
Off Street: 1
Garage Location
None: 1
Extras
Cable: 1
For Commercial Land
Gas Available: No
Raw Land: Yes
Survey: Yes
Features
Apartment: 1
Mixed Use: 1
Retail: 1
Other: 1
Building Info
Building Available SqFt: 14250
Retail Available SqFt: 4200
Sprinklers: No
Construction
Concrete Block: 1
Frame: 1
Frame Brick: 1
AddressLegal
Street No.: 162-166
Street Name: St Marys
Street Suffix: Avenue
County: Richmond
State: NY
Zip Code: 10305
Area Name: Rosebank
Parcel ID: 02972-0070
ContractLocation Information
Status: Active
Marketing/Listing Date: 2025-12-05
List Price: $3,499,999
Current Price: $3,499,999
Sub-Type: Mixed Use
Zoning: R-3A
Block: 02972
Lot: 0070
Property Features
Electric Meters: Individual
Garage Location: None
Extras: Cable
Expenses Include: Insurance; Taxes; Utilities
Gas Meters: Individual
Use Restrictions: None
Heat Source: Gas
Heat System: Hot Water
Showing Instructions: Call Agent
Electric: 220
Features: Apartment; Mixed Use; Retail; Other
Construction: Concrete Block; Frame; Frame Brick
Parking: Off Street
Listing Courtesy of Toscana Property LLC
Listing data provided courtesy of Staten Island Multiple Listing Service. The information being provided is for consumers personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
